Detroit Mayor’s Affair Costs City $9 Million! Choice and Consequences – Ethics Speaker Chuck Gallagher Comments

Lies and deception!


Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick and his chief of staff, Christine Beatty five years ago were having an affair. The lies and deception that followed cost the City of Detroit more than $9 million dollars, and cost former police officers their career.

But, every choice has a consequence. As a business ethics speaker (, I share that sentiment with audiences nation wide. You can run but you cannot hide – from the truth. It is said that you reap what you sow. Most of the people who find themselves facing consequences they did not anticipate – assume that if they are not caught or can cover up the truth – what is hidden will stay that way forever. That is further from the truth. Funny, but “truth” has a way of sneaking to the surface.

A story by Paul Anger of the Detroit Free Press exemplifies this as it relates to Mayor Kilpatrick’s actions (segments of the story are reprinted here):

In October, the city paid a whopping settlement to three victims — former Deputy Police Chief Gary Brown and former officers Harold Nelthrope and Walt Harris. A jury had decided that Brown and Nelthrope were punished unfairly by the mayor for doing their jobs, for what they knew or might find out about the mayor. After vowing to appeal the jury’s whistle-blower verdict, the mayor abruptly gave up and settled with all three. And the city had to scrounge up the settlement money.

Actions yield consequences: The mayors actions – lies and deceptions – designed to keep his affair secret ultimately had a price. I’m sure the officers in question, while receiving compensation for their loss, would rather have had a normal career where they would have been rewarded for doing their job, rather than living through a “hell” imposed by an out of control mayor.

Kudos to the Detroit Free Press as they report:

In the wake of that, the Free Press set out to find the truth. Why would the mayor and the city grind through years of legal battles over the officers, only to lose so badly? Why, after all those years, and his initial what he called “blown away” reaction to the verdict, did Kilpatrick finally agree to settle? Were there any documents, beyond he-said, she-said, they-said, that would answer the questions?

We knew that some Beatty text messages from 2002 and 2003 had been subpoenaed but never showed up in court. We knew the city fought to block them. So we started down two paths — we went to court to get all documents related to the settlement, and listened to what sources were telling us.

Some of the most skilled people I’ve worked with in 40-plus years in journalism went after the answers: Herschel Fink, one of the nation’s foremost First Amendment lawyers, and reporters Jim Schaefer and M.L. Elrick. They’re still chasing the truth, in court and out, and the mayor and the city are still fighting to contain the damage.

The reports of misconduct – lies and deception go deep in Detroit. Last Thursday, the Free Press revealed that Kilpatrick and his chief of staff, Christine Beatty, lied under oath at the trial that led to the payouts. The newspaper obtained text messages from Beatty’s city-issued pager, showing they gave false testimony when they denied having an affair that might have been exposed by the police probe. The two face potential perjury charges.

Every choice has a consequence! Wonder now if the Mayor feel that the affair was worth the potential ramifications of his actions? Remember Scooter Libby was convicted and sentenced to prison for perjury. (Of course in Libby’s case he did have a friend in high places). Wonder how Mayor Kilpatrick will feel about potential prison if it is determined that his lies and deceptions were criminal?

Columnist Ron Dzwonkowski wrote these comments: “You just never know, I guess, which of the hidden character defects in all of us is going to surface and mess with destiny. The very ego that made Kilpatrick so confident he could be mayor at a very young age also seems to have convinced him he could do as he pleased and get away with it. Sometimes, it’s not good to win too much; you get to feeling you can’t lose, and that’s when you’re most vulnerable.”

That, I must admit, is one of the most astute paragraphs I’ve ever read as it pertains to those whose choices cross the line and who ultimately pay the price. Which hidden character defect will surface and mess with destiny? More times than not, as I address groups on white collar crime, it comes to the surface that those who commit those crimes are not “criminals” in the sense most people perceive, but rather, that hidden character defect surfaces and reeks havoc.

The thought of believing that you could do as you please and get away with it…well that’s the key. Though I am not proud of the fact, but as a white collar criminal, I, too, had a big ego and felt that I would not get caught. I had it all figured out. But just as Dzwonkowski said, “it’s not good to win too much; you get to feeling you can’t lose, and that’s when you’re most vulnerable.” Just when you think you can lose is the very time when the consequences start to come into place. And, most of the time, we don’t like the consequences that follow.

Questions: What consequences should Kilpatrick experience as a result of his lies and deceit? Do you feel that the shame, if any, of this public exposure is consequence enough? Since Kilpatrick was elected at age 31 making him Detroit’s youngest mayor – should there be an age limit for mayoral qualification?

The details reported by are contained in the link provided. City Funds Link

3 Responses to Detroit Mayor’s Affair Costs City $9 Million! Choice and Consequences – Ethics Speaker Chuck Gallagher Comments

  1. Kam says:

    clinton cheated in his fifties so age limits matter not.

  2. Vertel Patterson says:

    Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick needs to be a man and not a scary little snot nose punk his malicous behavior proved only one thing that he has a lot of growing up to do.He looks down on the majority of his citizens like he is so perfect when the truth is he displays as much criminal activity as a every day lowlife that you would see standing on the corner looking for trouble.This man is the youngest mayor that ever lived and that,s why it is sad to see him act like this instead of doing what,s right and get rid of people who really caused this city to be so far behind.Like for example,people who discriminate.My mom was born and raised in Detriot and before she was discriminated against by our locals she always talked about some of her most memorable momments in Detroit and now, she,s embarrassed to even tell people that she was born there.These discriminators should be put away and tought a lesson for commtiting hate crime and conspiracy against someone based on there sexual preference.Mr ego Kilpatrick does,nt deal with these issues does he?He,s too busy hiring thugs,screwing hookers, cheating on his wife,and cheating his citizens out of 9 million dollars so he could cover his fat ass like that,s possible.This man is a discrace to black people and now, i,m pretty sure that the prejudice whites will make a example of him because to them this is the moment that they were waiting for.So get ready citizens of Detroit!!! because you are about to be held down more than ever and you have no one to blame but yourself because you voted for this clown twice.Let this be a lesson to all of you to stop being lazy and get whatever it is that you want in life yourself and don,t wait on authority to simply give hand-outs to you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: