For some time I have been writing and speaking about white collar crime, business ethics and the issue of mortgage fraud. Then we have the issues that have surfaced over the past several weeks culminating with the President’s address tonight. A major recession (I’d call it a depression) is facing us if we don’t do something now.
Now just may be too late. Many individuals and firms have either gone under or become the target of a massive FBI investigation into mortgage fraud over the past several years. But at the heart of this entire mess is the government and their failure to provide oversight and accountability. It seemed that a robust economy balanced on the back of home ownership was more important than practical long term ethical decisions that fall on the backs of our elected officials. (And for anyone who feels that I am leaning one way or the other politically – I feel there is plenty of blame for all elected officials).
Now we find in published reports that the FBI is expanding it’s investigation of major institutions whose names have been at the heart of the meltdown we are today witnessing.
According to CNN:
The FBI is investigating Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Lehman Brothers and AIG – and their executives – as part of a broad look into possible mortgage fraud, sources with knowledge of the investigation told CNN Tuesday.
Two officials with knowledge of the FBI investigation into the mortgage crisis said “the investigation is all very preliminary”. They said there is a lot of anger and people want someone held accountable.
Officials are looking into whether any criminal activity occurred, but the Bureau said the investigation will take some time. They said the investigation is in the preliminary stages, and so far it is a broad look at the companies involved.
“From what I’ve seen so far, I really don’t believe we’re going to find widespread fraud,” according to one of the officials. They said they have to go where evidence and facts lead. Just because an investigation has been opened doesn’t mean there will be charges.
Trust me – there will not be charges. The FBI investigation (done by well meaning people) is just a political smoke screen so that those who want accountability will feel that something is being done. Frankly, nothing substantive will be done to hold those most accountable for this financial failure responsible.
As reported in my prior blog entries, FBI Director Robert Mueller told Congress that 1,400 individual real estate lenders, brokers and appraisers are now under investigation in addition to two dozen corporations. What is of most interest is that the focus is on small time fish and a big sea of corruption.
Greenspan told Congress sometime in the recent past that something must be done with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae or we would face a meltdown and grave financial crisis. His prediction has come true. What’s sad is that our politicians from both sides of the isle did not have the fortitude to step up and do the right thing. Rather, they buried their head in the sand and now find that they are drowning in a sea of financial misfortune.
ENRON’s leaders were held criminally liable for their financial misdeeds. This collapse makes the ENRON mess pale in comparison. Yet, since government backed Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae are at the heart of the problem – both backing poor loans and selling them to the market – there will be nothing criminal to come from this. The government doesn’t have the will or courage to regulate itself – nor the ethical wisdom to do what is right.
Cynical – well not really. Practical – yes. This $700 billion dollar plan will in the end cost $3 TRILLION…just wait and see. Meanwhile, there is a long winter ahead and the chill we will feel won’t just be the weather.
QUESTION: Do you believe the FBI will find anyone in any major institution recently names held criminally liable?