Freedom of Speech or Consequences of foul language – You tell me! Isaac Rosenbloom vs. Barbara Pyle

Don Troop, an author featured in The Chronicle of Higher Education wrote the following – presented in full:

An F (Bomb) in Oral Communications

Isaac Rosenbloom was among a small group of students who stuck around after speech class one day this spring at Hinds Community College to discuss their grades with the instructor.

After seeing that he had received a 74 on a late assignment, Mr. Rosenbloom testified in a recorded disciplinary hearing, he turned to one of his peers and said, “this grade is going to [expletive] up my entire GPA.” He says the instructor, Barbara Pyle, heard him and “went into a screaming fit,” telling him that she does not tolerate offensive language and threatening to send him to detention.

“I told her, ‘This is college, and I’m 30 years old,'” Mr. Rosenbloom testified. “‘There is no detention.'”

After being summoned to the dean’s office, Mr. Rosenbloom sought the assistance of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, the free-speech advocacy group, which issued a statement defending the right of adults to use naughty words.

“It is quite absurd that a college has decided that a 29-year-old man who uses a four-letter word out of frustration after a class should be officially punished,” FIRE Vice President Robert Shibley said in a statement. “College students don’t lose their free speech rights when they arrive on campus. Will Hinds be sending its students to bed without supper next?”

While Mr. Rosenbloom is actually being disciplined for “flagrant disrespect,” FIRE wrote President Clyde Muse to tell him that the college’s speech policies are unconstitutional and were “applied unconstitutionally to punish Rosenbloom for his protected speech outside of class.” The college bans “public profanity, cursing, and vulgarity.” Violators can be fined $25 to $50 or, for a third offense, be suspended from college.

According to FIRE, Mr. Rosenbloom was banned from Ms. Pyle’s course and given 12 demerits (three short of suspension). In addition, a description of the case is being placed on his permanent record.

An appeal to President Muse is pending.

So…as I often report on choices and consequences…and ethics, this article seems interesting.  It raises an excellent question or set of questions.

  1. Should an adult have the freedom of speech to express his/her frustration without retribution or negative consequence?
  2. Is it constitutional for an institution of higher learning to impose a limit on speech for it’s students or employees?
  3. Was the instructor’s reaction to the words uttered appropriate?
  4. Lastly, if what you say offends me, should I have the right to limit your freedom of speech?  If so, where is the limit drawn between what offends me and your rights to express yourself?

I would hope that readers might be willing to express themselves and weigh in on whose right carries the greatest weight.


3 Responses to Freedom of Speech or Consequences of foul language – You tell me! Isaac Rosenbloom vs. Barbara Pyle

  1. ben says:

    1.fuckyeah they should so should kids in my oppion thats y we have freedom of speech the government just decided to intrperate it there way, it says freedom of speech not freedom of speech with limatations of what the government says. the people were given the power not the government.

    2.depends where your at and what time like u shouldnt holler it but u should if ur muttering to ur self or talking to a friend not at all he muttered it to a friend it was a mistake that was handle

    4.FUCK NO!

  2. afdfdsf says:

    Hi i would like to borrow this picture to show my opposition to cybercrime law in our country. It denies us the right to speak online against our corrupt and unjust leaders. :/

  3. Hello,
    the Foundation KARTA Center is conducting an educational project about human rights and history and we prepare a publication with scenarios of workshops for students relating the topic. The project and the publication are non-comercial. The publication will have its online version and can be downloaded by teachers, librarians, educators.
    We wanted to use in the scenario about freedom of speech the image:

    Could we use it for free? We write down of course the name of the author (if you give it to us) and your webside as a source.

    Thank you very much for the answer.
    Best regards,
    Agnieszka Kudełka
    tel. 0048 848 07 12

Leave a Reply to afdfdsf Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: